name

2116 CASEY KEY RD

  • NOKOMIS, FL
  • $6,995,000
$6,995,000

2116 CASEY KEY RD

3 Beds 4 Baths 5,590 Sq.Ft. 0.58 Acres

Description

Gulf-to-Bay estate on Casey Key offering rare, deeded private beach access directly across the street and deep-water frontage on Blackburn Bay. Set on more than a half-acre, this elevated coastal residence spans more than 5,500 square feet and delivers a true dual-waterfront lifestyle with boating on one side and the Gulf of Mexico on the other.
The bayfront setting is designed for outdoor living and entertaining, featuring a multi-level tropical environment with expansive pavered decks, covered lounge areas, a gazebo dining space, and an open pool terrace with heated swimming pool and spa (resurfaced with a PebbleTec finish). A second-level screened bayfront patio provides a tranquil vantage point overlooking the water. The extended dock, updated in 2018, includes a lift and offers deep-water access with no fixed bridges--ideal for sailboat or powerboat use and direct passage to the bay and Gulf.
Inside, cathedral ceilings and walls of oversized impact windows and sliders frame sweeping views of the bay while filling the home with natural light. The layout is well suited for guests and multi-generational living. The first floor includes a family room, game room, office with built-ins, two guest bedroom suites, and a convenient kitchenette. The second floor is dedicated to the main living spaces, featuring a bay-view living room, dining room, granite kitchen with island and informal dining area, stainless steel appliances, wet bar with wine cooler, and the primary bedroom suite with en-suite bath. A three-stop elevator and stair access connect all levels.
Significant updates include a metal roof replacement (2022), multiple A/C changeouts (2017-2024), replacement of non-impact windows with Anderson impact windows, updated dock pilings and lift pilings, new ductwork, electrical upgrades, and re-piping--providing long-term confidence for coastal ownership.
Located on the quiet southern end of Casey Key, this estate offers a private island setting while remaining close to everyday conveniences. Enjoy easy access to Nokomis Beach, Venice Island dining and shopping, marinas, and the Legacy Trail. Downtown Sarasota's cultural venues, golf courses, and waterfront attractions are within a short drive, making this a distinctive opportunity to enjoy Gulf beaches, boating, and refined coastal living in one of Sarasota County's most exclusive barrier-island communities.

Share Property

Location

2116 CASEY KEY RD, NOKOMIS, FL 34275

Status

For Sale

1984

1984

Year Built

3

3

Total Bedrooms

4

4

Total Bathrooms

5,590

5,590

Sq.Ft.

Living Space

0.58

0.58

Acres

Lot Size

2.0

2.0

Garage Spaces

image

Schedule a Tour

We would love to show you our beautiful property. Please select your preferred date and time below. An agent will be in touch shortly to confirm your appointment.

Schedule a Tour

We would love to show you our beautiful property. Please select your preferred date and time below. An agent will be in touch shortly to confirm your appointment.

Thank you for your interest in 2116 CASEY KEY RD, NOKOMIS, FL 34275. We are reviewing your request and will be in touch shortly!
thumbnail
01

Interior

Total Bedrooms

3

Total Bathrooms

4

Full Bathrooms

3

Half Bathroom

1

Laundry room

Inside, Laundry Room

Flooring

Carpet, Tile, Wood

Fireplace

Living Room, Stone

Appliances

Built-In Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer, Wine Refrigerator

Other Interior Features

Built-in Features, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fans(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Elevator, High Ceilings, Primary Bedroom Upstairs, Solid Surface Counters, Split Bedroom, Stone Counters, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Wet Bar, Window Treatments
01

Exterior & Building

Stories

3

Garage Spaces

2.0

Water Source

Public

Utilities

Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Phone Available, Public, Sprinkler Well, Water Connected

Pool

Deck, Gunite, In Ground

Roof

Metal

Lot Features

Flood Zone, In County, Landscaped, Oversized Lot, Sidewalk

Parking

Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Ground Level, Guest

Heat Type

Central, Electric, Zoned

Air Conditioning

Central Air, Zoned

Sewer

Septic Tank

Substructure

Slab

Security Features

Secured Garage/Parking

Other Exterior Features

Balcony, French Doors, Lighting, Private Entrance, Private Mailbox, Private Yard, Sliding Doors
01

Lot & Area

Status

For Sale

Living Area

5,590 Sq.Ft.

Total Area

7,566 Sq.Ft.

Lot Size

0.58 Acres

MLS® ID

A4682484

Type

Residential

Year Built

1984

Neighborhood

Casey Key

Architecture Styles

Custom, Elevated

Water Frontage

Bay/Harbor

View Description

Pool,Water

Elementary School

Laurel Nokomis Elementary

Middle School

Sarasota Middle

High School

Venice Senior High
01

Finance

Sales Price

$6,995,000

Real Estate Taxes

$25,410/yr

Zoning

RE2

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, property taxes, and HOA. Adjust the values to generate a more accurate rate.
All estimates are provided for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.
$0,000 Your Payment 20 15 65
$0,000 Your Payment

Explore

Casey Key

Exclusive, tranquil remote barrier island with waterfront manors, cozy beach bungalows, and easy access to Sarasota.

Welcome to Casey Key

 

As the southernmost key of the West Coast Florida barrier island chain stretching upward toward Siesta Key, Casey Key is a narrow, resort-quality spot of paradise bursting with vibrant sunshine and lined with rows upon rows of palm and pine trees. A peaceful, sleepy enclave tucked away in Sarasota County, Casey Key is considered a hidden gem and an exclusive, affluent community that’s home to several huge stars, such as acclaimed author Stephen King. 

Known for being intimate and secure, Casey Key is a relatively small, residential place to live, but it provides easy access to the mainland across its singular main road. To get to the stylish boutiques and culinary delights of Sarasota, you only have to drive a short distance! 

What to Love

  • Healthy lifestyle
  • Moderate climate, gorgeous weather
  • Easy access to Sarasota
  • Beachside living
  • Historic mansions
  • Private and exclusive

People & Lifestyle 

Residents in Casey Key are accustomed to luxury. Here, you'll find numerous historic mansions brimming with charm alongside the sandy coastline with a mix of well-styled modern homes spread throughout. There is no shortage of things to do in this coastal community, especially if you enjoy the outdoors. The North Jetty Park is popular for fishing and sunbathing. 

With easy access to Sarasota, locals can take a short drive into the city, ranked as one of the top art destinations in the nation for small cities! Home to less than 500 residents, Casey Key consists mainly of beach bungalows, waterfront mansions, and a few condos. It's one of the most secluded and remote islands around—perfect for retirees and professionals seeking vacation homes or somewhere reclusive to relax in peace and serenity.  

Dining, Entertainment & Shopping

Casey Key Fish House epitomizes beachside dining. From the on-site boat, kayak, and jet ski rentals to the waterfront tiki bar surrounded by pristine white sand, this little enclave is a local staple that serves delicious, moderately-priced food to boot! Every seat in the bay dining room offers astounding views of the water, and you can drive your boat right up to the dock.

Initially built in the early 1900s as a fish camp, Pelican Alley is a Nokomis institution and tourist destination. Come for their famous seafood chowder and stay to hear local legends, including a few hauntings. Writers, artists, celebrities, and more have visited this casual waterfront restaurant, which comes alive with music every Friday night.

The Breakfast Cottage is the best place around for a delicious breakfast or lunch. Housed in a quaint building with a broad patio, you can sit outside and enjoy the sea breeze while dining. Pop's Sunset Grill is another laid-back waterfront eatery with delicious sandwiches, burgers, and seafood classics. 

Top off your day at the beach or end a blissful evening drive with your family with a stop at Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream—they have heaping servings and plenty of flavors! 

Things to Do

North Jetty Park is one of the most popular parks and beaches in the area. Watch the boats pass through the channel, go fishing on the pier, hike along the trails, watch the local wildlife, or relax with a picnic at the beach in one of its many shady spots. 

Speaking of beaches, that's probably where you'll spend a significant amount of time since it’s one of the biggest draws to the area. Apart from North Jetty, you'll find Caspersen Beach, Turtle Beach, Lido Key, and Sarasota Bay nearby. 

If you're a boat owner who frequents the water, you might consider joining the Casey Key Marina & Yacht Club, which offers extensive services, fantastic staff who are happy to assist, and high-end equipment. 

Nestled between Sarasota and Venice near Osprey is the Oscar Scherer State Park, which features amenities such as the Legacy Trail, several beaches, boating, canoeing, fishing, snorkeling, and swimming. Surrounded by several major highways, the park is a natural oasis in the middle of commercial development and a gorgeous place to check out local wildlife, such as the nesting bald eagles during the winter. 

Welcome to Casey Key As the southernmost key of the West Coast Florida barrier island chain stretching upward toward Siesta Key, Casey Key is a narrow, resort-quality spot of paradise bursting with vibrant sunshine and lined with rows upon rows of palm and pine trees. A peaceful, sleepy enclave tucked away in Sarasota County, Casey Key is considered a hidden gem and an exclusive, affluent community that’s home to several huge stars, such as acclaimed author Stephen King. Known for being intimate and secure, Casey Key is a relatively small, residential place to live, but it provides easy access to the mainland across its singular main road. To get to the stylish boutiques and culinary delights of Sarasota, you only have to drive a short distance! What to Love Healthy lifestyle Moderate climate, gorgeous weather Easy access to Sarasota Beachside living Historic mansions Private and exclusive People & Lifestyle Residents in Casey Key are accustomed to luxury. Here, you'll find numerous historic mansions brimming with charm alongside the sandy coastline with a mix of well-styled modern homes spread throughout. There is no shortage of things to do in this coastal community, especially if you enjoy the outdoors. The North Jetty Park is popular for fishing and sunbathing. With easy access to Sarasota, locals can take a short drive into the city, ranked as one of the top art destinations in the nation for small cities! Home to less than 500 residents, Casey Key consists mainly of beach bungalows, waterfront mansions, and a few condos. It's one of the most secluded and remote islands around—perfect for retirees and professionals seeking vacation homes or somewhere reclusive to relax in peace and serenity. Dining, Entertainment & Shopping Casey Key Fish House epitomizes beachside dining. From the on-site boat, kayak, and jet ski rentals to the waterfront tiki bar surrounded by pristine white sand, this little enclave is a local staple that serves delicious, moderately-priced food to boot! Every seat in the bay dining room offers astounding views of the water, and you can drive your boat right up to the dock. Initially built in the early 1900s as a fish camp, Pelican Alley is a Nokomis institution and tourist destination. Come for their famous seafood chowder and stay to hear local legends, including a few hauntings. Writers, artists, celebrities, and more have visited this casual waterfront restaurant, which comes alive with music every Friday night. The Breakfast Cottage is the best place around for a delicious breakfast or lunch. Housed in a quaint building with a broad patio, you can sit outside and enjoy the sea breeze while dining. Pop's Sunset Grill is another laid-back waterfront eatery with delicious sandwiches, burgers, and seafood classics. Top off your day at the beach or end a blissful evening drive with your family with a stop at Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream—they have heaping servings and plenty of flavors! Things to Do North Jetty Park is one of the most popular parks and beaches in the area. Watch the boats pass through the channel, go fishing on the pier, hike along the trails, watch the local wildlife, or relax with a picnic at the beach in one of its many shady spots. Speaking of beaches, that's probably where you'll spend a significant amount of time since it’s one of the biggest draws to the area. Apart from North Jetty, you'll find Caspersen Beach, Turtle Beach, Lido Key, and Sarasota Bay nearby. If you're a boat owner who frequents the water, you might consider joining the Casey Key Marina & Yacht Club, which offers extensive services, fantastic staff who are happy to assist, and high-end equipment. Nestled between Sarasota and Venice near Osprey is the Oscar Scherer State Park, which features amenities such as the Legacy Trail, several beaches, boating, canoeing, fishing, snorkeling, and swimming. Surrounded by several major highways, the park is a natural oasis in the middle of commercial development and a gorgeous place to check out local wildlife, such as the nesting bald eagles during the winter.
Show more

Let’s connect

Thank you for your message

We will be in touch with you shortly

name

Thank you for your message

We will be in touch with you shortly

Let’s connect

Roger Pettingell

EM

Roger Pettingell

Founder & Luxury Waterfront Property Specialist

Roger Pettingell is a nationally recognized leader in Sarasota and Manatee Counties’ luxury waterfront real estate market, known for his record-breaking success and white-glove client experience.

Show more